TRIALS FLYING

14 - Boscombe Down and A V Roe

As stated in the previous chapter, Wing Commander John Brignell had invited me to join his squadron when the current course at Manby ended. There were still a few weeks to run before the move. During this time the Manby grapevine gave me news that the Flight Lieutenant Personal Assistant (PA) to the C-in-C Training Command (also based at Manby) had been due to be posted, and was asked by his master if he had any preference for his next tour of duty. The PA had heard of my good news and asked the C-in-C (Air Marshal Constantine) if he could go to the Handling Squadron at Boscombe Down too. Constantine was known to be a powerful figure in the RAF and so I had visions of bad luck approaching once more. The Handling Squadron vacancy was in the 'Fighter' Flight of the Squadron and there were no other vacancies available.

John Brignell then telephoned me and gave an account of his difficulties. He said he was now in the position of having promised me the job and of having had it approved by the postings authority, yet being pressurised by Constantine to drop me in favour of his PA who, in John's estimation did not have the sort of experience needed for the post.

The solution came in a tragic way. Another vacancy on the Handling Squadron arose when the Canberra project pilot of the squadron's 'Heavy' Flight was killed whilst carrying out safety-speed trials on a Canberra B8. John Brignell knew that I was a very experienced pilot who had flown a good number of hours on the Canberra and had a fair crop of types of aircraft registered in my log book. He telephoned again and asked if I thought I could hack the 'Heavy' Flight vacancy. He advised that I would have to complete the unfinished work on the Canberra B8 and that my next major project would be to carry out the whole trial on the first production Avro Vulcan to come off the assembly line at the end of the year. I gave thanks to all the Gods plus some, for not only having saved my Boscombe Down posting but for having given me one which would broaden my flying experience considerably. When the posting notice arrived on my desk with a date of 25 May 1956 on it, I breathed a sigh of relief - something had gone right as I approached the final phase of my flying career. The C-in-C's PA, who took the job in the 'Fighter' Flight in place of me, was tragically killed in a Supermarine Swift accident some time later.

On my first day at Boscombe Down, I reported to Wing Commander Brignell for duty. After his welcome and a brief talk on events to come, he told me to get into my flying kit and said there was a hot-rod on the tarmac waiting for me, a Mk 6 Hunter with the new 200 Series engine - a deal more powerful than the 100 Series Avon of the Mk 4s which I had left behind at Manby. It certainly was exhilarating. But it is odd how quickly one gets used to any improvement in power and performance, and how one never stops looking for more! My next flight was in a Fairey Firefly, a demonstration of the variety expected at this unit. I was going to enjoy this, I thought.

I then let it be known that I was in the market to capture as many aircraft types as I could and gladly took the opportunity to get to know my future project aircraft by cadging dual and second-pilot work on some of the pre-production test aircraft on the base, eg Vulcan and Vickers Valiant, new Marks of Canberra etc. I mentioned to the commander of the A&AEE 'C' Squadron, the Royal Naval test squadron, that he had a number of aircraft on his books which I would like to sample in exchange for a promise for him to sit alongside me in my Vulcan, when it arrived. It was bribery, but there were few ethics in this game. I therefore flew the de Havilland Sea Venom, Sea Devon, Sea Prince and Sea Vixen, the Hawker Sea Hawk, in addition to our own Firefly and Fairey Gannet 4, which the RN had transferred to us on permanent loan. And I allocate a special place on this list to the Short Sea Mew, which was withdrawn before entering service, so I must have been one of only a few to have flown it. This pleasant little single Mamba-engined aircraft had one peculiarity, a distinctive automatic change of rudder position coincident with the selection of the flaps to the down setting; was this to pander to weak-kneed pilots? I never did find the answer, but I took fiendish delight one day when I was running in to join the Boscombe circuit in a Hunter and I heard a Navy pilot transmit from a Sea Mew "There's something wrong with the controls of this aircraft - the rudder pedals have just moved right on their own". He must have blushed brilliant scarlet when he heard me chip in "That's what they're supposed to do". I fancy he cringed at this exposure of his failure to read the pilot's operating notes for the type!

My Sea Vixen sortie was a bit of a laugh for me but not for my 'navigator' Flight Lieutenant John Cordery, the Handling Squadron adjutant. Everything was fine until I got to 50ft on the glidepath on the final approach to land, when suddenly my ejection seat raise/lower lever slipped out of its slot and the seat thundered down to the bottom of its travel. "Holy Moses" I yelled. "I can hardly see!". My navigator's required sitting position for landing was such that he couldn't see either. The aircraft was too low for me to try to recover the seat position I lately had, and in any case I was too busy with both hands occupied on throttle and control column to do anything about it. I had only a small area above the cockpit coaming to view ahead for the flare and landing, which I executed without much bother. But I had scared John out of his wits, for he was unsure whether or not we were in serious trouble.

My next 'sea' aeroplane sortie was rather more serious. The RN rang me up to ask me to fly a Sea Hawk at low level over the English Channel to act as stooge for a radar trial for two Sea Vixens. It was one of those days when the visibility had reduced to being measured in yards instead of miles, usually called goldfish-bowl weather. The Sea Vixens would be tracking my aircraft on their radar from various distances behind me, and on various headings announced by them. This was to be right out to mid-channel, so there would be no land in sight to relate to, just water merging into mist, with no visible horizon at all. I would have preferred to have been flying on instruments, but not at that height (50 to 100ft above the sea). I began to feel an odd sensation, almost vertigo, and I also felt myself tightening up, which made matters worse. I had to remain at low level, or the exercise would be wasted. I was sure I was about to make the biggest splash of my life! I just hung on as best I could and prayed for the time to speed up to finish the torture. Several times I was about to pack it in and climb to get some distance between me and the sea. Eventually, after what seemed like hours, a glimpse of land appeared and I recovered. I didn't ever find out what had caused the feeling. It may have been a problem with the balancing semi-circular canals in my ears, or a psycho- logical hypnosis (whatever that is) but I had never experienced it before, nor have I since. It was not pleasant. Perhaps it was just plain unadulterated terror!

My next target was 'D' Squadron (the A&AEE transport specialists) to add one more to my types flown. I was asked to co-pilot a Blackburn Beverley. Remember it? A short-haul elephantine transport aircraft which had the ability to taxy backwards to make parking easier. We made some live drops of stores platforms, which I enjoyed; it reminded me of my Dakota

days. Then, one morning in July, my next type arrived from Hatfield. It was the de Havilland Comet, the Mk 2C version for transport use by the RAF. We needed it only briefly to resolve

a possible handling problem which might be encountered if the control column was pulled to the limit of elevator travel on take-off, the fear being that the bottom of the rear fuselage might contact the ground in these conditions. But our 'Heavy' Flight concluded that it would not, after all of us had tried to make it happen. I really enjoyed handling the aircraft, but I found the control harmonisation of elevators and ailerons not too well balanced. The ailerons required a firm breakout force to apply them (at any airspeed, I seem to recall), but not so for the elevators. Too soon, the aircraft was whisked away to join its squadron - No 216 I seem to remember, at RAF Lyneham in Wiltshire.

I had my own work to deal with though; it was not just collecting types for showing off in the log book. I found the B8 Canberra to be a really pleasant Mark of the aircraft, the best of the bunch unless you count the Royal New Zealand Air Force's B12, which just had the edge; it was identical to the B8 but had the additional comfort of an efficient air-conditioning system, which you needed badly in hot summer weather. I found, as did many whose early aviation background was in the fighter role, that the B8's cockpit layout was much preferable to that of the B2 and B6 variants, especially the change to a fighter-type pistol-grip control column which did away with the need for the snatch-unit required to pull your legs clear of the spectacled control column if you had to use the ejection seat.

The really serious work was approaching and, when not flying, I was committed to my desk going through the technical manuals on the various systems of the Vulcan, until I knew these systems thoroughly. But before the dramatic events of that period unfolded, I experienced helicopter flying for the first time. The RN Lieutenant Commander of our 'Fighter' Flight had a somewhat prolonged trial to do on the Westland Dragonfly and with some spare time left until the machine had to be returned whence it came, he ran a small course to convert all available pilots in the Squadron to the tricky art. This was in the days without auto-throttle control. Not easy at first - you had to put flaring to land out of your mind or you would find yourself going backwards.

* * * * *

It was in the autumn of that year, 1956, that the aircraft which I had awaited for all these months since May was towed off the assembly line at A V Roe's factory at Woodford - Vulcan XA 897. But a delay in delivery to me occurred. I was notified by John Brignell that the Air Ministry had agreed to a request from C-in-C Bomber Command Air Marshal Sir Harry Broadhurst (heir-apparent chairman of A V Roe) to allow XA 897 to be loaned temporarily to himself and A V Roe's resident Bomber Command liaison officer (a serving Squadron Leader) to fly it out to Australia to make some publicity flights over Melbourne prior to the opening of the 16th Olympic Games there. So my Vulcan had been pinched. After the departure of XA 897 for Australia, the Vulcan OCU at RAF Waddington received its first Vulcan XA 895 from the factory. You will need to know this as you read on.

I was sitting in the ante-room of the Boscombe Down mess just before lunch on a dreadful day, October 1, with monsoon conditions prevailing outside. The radio was on when the programme was interrupted for a special announcement that a Vulcan aircraft had crashed on approach to landing at London's Heathrow Airport, in which the rear crew of three had been killed but that both pilots had ejected safely. After a stunned silence, there was a buzz of conversation from the assembled officers and those associated with the Vulcan project made guesses as to what could have caused the disaster. It was my aircraft, of course. News of the tragedy began to filter in. The latest was that the aircraft had flown down the glidepath on a radar-controlled instrument approach (known as a ground controlled approach - GCA) but had disappeared off the screen at about a mile from the runway threshold, had hit the ground in the undershoot area, bounced into the air and then crashed on to the airfield. Any further guessing as to the cause of the crash was a waste of time; nothing sure would be known until the findings of the investigation board and the Accidents Investigation Branch report, were published. Yet even with my few hours on the type as co-pilot, I thought I knew how the accident had happened; but I need to set the scene for my hypothesis.

The Handling Squadron had a requirement to provide 'fixed' engine RPM settings for use on the approach and glidepath phases of instrument landings. These fixed RPM settings had two purposes. Firstly, by being fixed they were designed to reduce the stress which the pilot suffers due to the number of parameters he must monitor, eg airspeed, rate-of-descent, height, attitude, heading and engine RPM. Secondly, the known RPM setting can be useful in the event of failure of the airspeed indication if no other aircraft is available to assist in landing.

I wrote an article on Vulcan instrument approaches in which I said: 'At the bottom of the QGH (D/F let-down) slope with the throttles at idling and high-drag airbrakes selected, airspeed is allowed to fall in order to permit the lowering of the undercarriage within its speed limits. A fixed RPM setting then gives comfortable control on finals. When the glidepath is intercepted, power is reduced once again to a fixed setting and the aircraft nosed down to give the desired rate-of-descent. Speed should now be maintained at about 20 knots above threshold speed, which ensures better speed control and forward view. If the aircraft is allowed to sink much below the glidepath, the excess speed alone may not be sufficient to regain height and a fair increase in RPM may be momentarily necessary to get back on the glidepath and to recover speed. When the runway is sighted, power may be reduced and the speed allowed to fall to the recommended figure.'